News

Statistical Anomalies from the Wisconsin Supreme Court Recount

May 21, 2011
Jim Jacobs

  • Read more
  • Share this
  • Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Colleagues see Nickolaus as insular, hardworking--Waukesha County clerk's error is at center of Supreme Court recount

    May 15, 2011
    Laurel Walker

    May 15, 2011 6:36 p.m.
    Waukesha - Kathy Nickolaus, the county clerk at the center of the state Supreme Court election controversy and the focus of an ongoing state elections investigation, has been described by colleagues and acquaintances as headstrong and insular, hardworking and independent.

    She came to local public office, where constituents are the boss, from a staff job at the state Capitol, where partisan politics and loyalty to the party caucus fomented team warfare.

    "I don't think she's ever gotten past that," said Pam Reeves, the Republican elected county treasurer two years before Nickolaus' arrival at the courthouse. "From the beginning she put up walls: 'You're not going to tell me what to do.' Then she put up more walls."

    Daily Kos: Wisconsin Recount, Days 17 & 18 - The Machines Will Save Us

    May 15, 2011
    Giles Goat Boy

    As it made clear at the start of the recount of Wisconsin's April 5th Supreme Court election, the agency in charge of administering that election is determined to prove to the people of Wisconsin that the votes were counted honestly and openly.

    As I have said since before the start of the recount, the Government Accountability Board (GAB) has a conflict of interest. The GAB is in charge of investigating allegations of illegal or unethical activities made against the people the GAB trains to run elections. Any fraud or incompetence the GAB might uncover among municipal and county clerks is an indictment of the GAB's ability to train and oversee those same clerks. The GAB has a huge incentive to avoid discovery of wrongdoing.

    Their dual role results in some conflicting explanations from them.

    AP: Walker's budget raises taxes on the poor

    May 15, 2011
    Associated Press

    MADISON, Wis. (AP) - A new nonpartisan analysis of Republican Gov. Scott Walker's budget proposal shows that it would raise taxes for poor people, while decreasing taxes overall.

    The Legislative Fiscal Bureau report shows that taxes for low and moderate income people would increase more than $49 million over two years. The largest increase comes to families who qualify for the earned income tax credit and homeowners who receive a homestead tax credit.

    Anne McClintock analyzes the recent uprising in Wisconsin

    May 13, 2011
    Anne McClintock

    On arriving in Madison some years ago, I went to the huge Farmers Market that winds round the Capitol. Startled by the slow-moving procession of orderly, white shoppers all pacing in the same direction, I dubbed the market throngs “The Million White Person March,” little imagining how in the spring of 2011 this deep-rooted Wisconsin sense of discipline, good-neighborliness and community pride would fire into the largest rallies in defense of labor rights and democratic process that the United States has seen in eighty years.

    Brian Pruka: WHAT I SAW IN WAUKESHA and WHY I AM CONCERNED

    May 11, 2011
    Brian Pruka


    On Monday, May 9th, I drove from Madison to Waukesha to observe the Waukesha County recount of the WI Supreme Court election. I observed from 2:30 pm until the day’s recount was finished at 7pm.

    I began the day as a citizen observer. Observers sit in the gallery, a row of chairs behind a line that separates them from those conducting the recount (the official “tabulators”) and campaign-designated observers who are allowed to look over the shoulders of the tabulators. As an citizen observer I was only 4-6 feet from the first row of tabulator tables. But I wasn’t close enough to actually read anything in the poll books or ballots or computer tally tapes being processed.

    BRADBLOG.COM: Many Problems Observed in Milwaukee 'Recount' of WI Supreme Court Election

    May 11, 2011
    "eowyn_of_rohan"

    But No Media Reports!:  Open ballot bags, mistallied ballots, high undervote rate, observation obscured and other unreported concerns...

    [BragBlog Ed Note: The following account from an observer at Milwaukee County's machine "recount" of ballots from Wisconsin's April 5th Supreme Court election between incumbent Republican David Prosser and independent Asst. Attorney General JoAnne Kloppenburg, comes on the heels of recently documented reports of complete chain of custody violations such as "wide open" ballots bags in Waukesha County --- where the stunning announcement of the addition of some 14,000 votes two days after the election reversed the originally reported results to give Prosser the unofficial lead over Kloppenburg for the 10-year seat on the state's highest court --- as well as earlier reports of ballots discovered unsecured for weeks in Dane County's city of Verona and unexplained variance

    PROTECTOURELECTIONS.ORG: Nonpartisan Advocacy Group Offers $25,000 Reward For Evidence of Tampering in Wisconsin's Supreme Court Election

    May 11, 2011

    WASHINGTON, May 5, 2011 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- ProtectOurElections.org today offered a $25,000 reward for "information leading to the arrest and conviction of any person or persons for election tampering, resulting in reversal of the current outcome of the April 5, 2011 Wisconsin Supreme Court election in which David Prosser is said to lead JoAnne Kloppenburg by more than 7,000 votes." A reward poster is located at http://www.velvetrevolution.us/images/SC-Reward.pdf.

     

    Waukesha Recount Eyewitness: Custody of Ballot Bags in Waukesha Raises Serious Concerns

    May 11, 2011
    James Mueller


    From: Jim Mueller, observer at the Waukesha County recount
    To: Citizens concerned about the integrity of the Waukesha County recount
    RE: Please encourage the (Kloppenburg) Campaign to insist that these steps listed below be taken. If the Board of Canvssers refuse, they look like they aren't doing a good job or ....?
    Date: Wed., May 11, 2011
     

    Following is an email message that I just sent to Melissa. (editor's note: Melissa Mulliken, campaign manager for The Kloppenburg for Justice committee).

    Melissa,

    The ongoing compromised state of ballot security in Waukesha County should be stopped immediately.

    BREAKING: Legislative committee recommends cuts to WI Arts Board

    May 6, 2011
    Patti Wenzel
    news photo

    The Joint Finance Committee voted today to end the independent agency status of the Wisconsin Arts Board, moving the oversight of arts to the Tourism Board. The proposal will now go before the State Assembly and Senate for final approval as part of Gov. Scott Walker’s 2011-13 biennial budget. The vote was along party lines with 14 Republicans voting in favor and four Democrats voting against.

    The committee did restore some of the cuts Walker proposed, returning over $350,000 to the agency over the next two years. The Board was facing a drop from $3 million to $750,000; now it will have just over $1 million in the next budget period.

    The JFC also reversed Walker by allowing the Arts Board the autonomy to select its own executive director in the future.

    WWW.BRADBLOG.COM: CITY OF BROOKFIELD BALLOT BAGS FOUND 'WIDE OPEN' IN WAUKESHA COUNTY, WI

    May 5, 2011
    Brad Friedman

    Five out of six bags of ballots from first batch to be counted out of the City of Brookfield in Waukesha County, WI today, were discovered "almost wide open" during Day 8 of the statewide Supreme Court election "recount". The bags were open and unsealed, according to both photographic evidence and an eye-witnesses account from the counting room. (Many more exclusive photos posted below.)

     "When the ballot bags were taken out and placed upon the counting table, we were literally stunned," one of the citizen observers, Mary Magnuson, a Kloppenburg volunteer, told The BRAD BLOG this morning. "5 out of the 6 ballot bags were almost literally wide open, and ballots could be clearly seen."

    Nonpartisan Advocacy Group Offers $25,000 Reward For Evidence of Tampering in Wisconsin's Supreme Court Election

    May 5, 2011
    www.protectourelections.org

    WASHINGTON, May 5, 2011 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- ProtectOurElections.org today offered a $25,000 reward for "information leading to the arrest and conviction of any person or persons for election tampering, resulting in reversal of the current outcome of the April 5, 2011 Wisconsin Supreme Court election in which David Prosser is said to lead JoAnne Kloppenburg by more than 7,000 votes." A reward poster is located at http://www.velvetrevolution.us/images/SC-Reward.pdf.

    Images from Waukesha County recount from today, Thursday, May 5, 2011

    May 5, 2011
    photos forwarded via Facebook

    The following three photos were sent by citizen observers at the Waukesha County recount this evening. Photos received at 7:15pm, Thursday, May 5th. The ballot bags pictured are from the city of Brookfield. Open ballot bags.

    BRADBLOG.COM: WI's Supreme Court Election 'Recount' is a Mess

    May 3, 2011
    Brad Friedman

    Wisconsin is no Minnesota.

    Where Minnesota's post-election hand count of the 2008 U.S. Senate election between then Sen. Norm Coleman and now Sen. Al Franken was, as we wrote at the UK's Guardian at the time, "one of the longest and most transparent election hand-counts in the history of the US," Wisconsin has made it extremely difficult (putting it nicely) to know what the hell is actually going on in their statewide "recount" of the April 5th, 2011 state Supreme Court election between Justice David Prosser and Asst. Attorney General JoAnne Kloppenburg.

    GAB Excel Spreadsheet: 47 Counties Still Working on Recount

    May 2, 2011
    Brian Pruka

    If you are interested in attending and watching the recount, below are listed the 47 Counties that still have voting recount data to report, according to the Excel spreadsheet published by the Wisconsin Accountability Board website at their 12:50pm, Tues., May 2nd Recount Daily Updates.

    By this evening it is likely that several of these counties will have finished their recount. I will try to have an update posted tonight after the GAB posts their Excel spreadsheet for the evening.

    Govt. Accountability Board: Recount Daily Updates (as of 12:50pm, Tuesday, May 2, 2011)

    May 2, 2011
    Government Accountability Board of Wisconsin

    Note: These are unofficial recount results that have not been certified by the G.A.B.

    As of 12:50 p.m. on Tuesday, May 2, 2011, 1,942 Reporting Units have reported results, which have been reviewed by G.A.B. staff.  That is approximately 54 percent of the of the 3,602 total Reporting Units.

    So far, counties have recounted 718,230 votes, which is approximately 48 percent of the original votes cast in the State Supreme Court race.

    There are 27 reporting units not included in this posting that have been reported but are being further reviewed by G.A.B. staff

    Govt. Accountability Board: Waupaca County Discovers Canvass Error

    May 2, 2011
    Government Accountability Board of Wisconsin

    Waupaca County officials have discovered two errors in the original canvass of the Supreme Court election.  Here is Waupaca County Clerk Mary Robbins' explanation to G.A.B. staff:

    Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce (WMC) Factsheet

    May 1, 2011

    What is WMC?

    Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce (WMC) is our state’s largest and most powerful business lobby group.  WMC’s mission is to further its over 4,000 corporate clients’ goal of transferring even more wealth from the working and middle classes and on to the rich.  Often nicknamed the “real capital” by political insiders, this nefarious institution is, more than any single large corporation or politician, directly responsible for the attacks on working people in Wisconsin over the past three decades.

    GESVAIN: Recount observers needed EVERYDAY 8am-8pm -- all districts

    May 1, 2011
    Karen Geszvain

    (Editor's Note: Wisconsin Wave does not endorse or support any campaign or campaign committee. The following posting was written by a recount volunteer for the Kloppenburg campaign. We are posting this for its information/news content only.

    Note that the only citizen recount monitors who are allowed to stand behind the official recount tabulators --and therefore the only citizen recount monitors who actually see the markings on the ballots-- are those monitors designated by one of the campaigns as a representative of their campaign.

    We citizens monitoring the recount as nonpartisans must sit in a gallery that is cordoned off from the tables where the ballots are being counted. We are not able to see the markings on the ballots, We are there to watch the proceedings to document how questioned ballots are dealt with.)

     

    The posting below is from a friend of mine who has been helping with the WI Supreme Court recount. Passing this on with her permission (sorry for the delay!).

    To help monitor the recount, just show up at the Dane County recount site (City County Building, 310 MLK Blvd, Room 354. Enter on Wilson St when building is closed.) any time today or future days from 8am to 8pm, or call the Kloppenburg campaign at 608/218-1203 to make arrangements for possible other places to help.
     
    Additionally, my same friend e-mailed me this this morning: "The lead Kloppenburg person said some mornings it has been only herself representing Kloppenburg from 8am until 11am or so, while Prosser has one observer for every poll worker. Prosser's people are also paid and they have at least one or more lawyers present. We didn't have a lawyer today and could have used one."
     
    The Kloppenburg campaign needs volunteers! I'll be there today.
     

    Post Your Recount Observations on this Webpage

    May 1, 2011
    Brian Pruka

    The Wisconsin Wave has established this webpage for citizens monitoring the Wisconsin Supreme Court recount as a place where we can share our news and observations.  Bookmark this page if you want the latest recount news from citizens on the scene at courthouses around the state.

    CAP TIMES: Missing Verona ballots cause glitch in Supreme Court race recount

    April 29, 2011
    Steven Elbow

    Newly appointed Dane County Clerk Karen Peters initially had doubts that the county could finish hand counting some 182,000 Supreme Court ballots within a 13-day deadline. But on Thursday she expressed confidence that it could be done.

    But that was before the glitch.

    Take Back the Land leads forclosure protest

    April 27, 2011
    Channel 3000

    Madison Group Protests M&I Bank Foreclosure- Protesters Say Housing Rights Are Human Rights
     
    MADISON, Wis. -- The Dane County Courthouse was the site for protests on Tuesday morning.Volunteers with Take Back the Land-Madison were protesting a home foreclosure by M&I Bank. They called for an end to bailing out the banks instead of people.

     

    Students rally against proposed "Badger Partnership"

    April 26, 2011
    Katherine Krueger

    Students organized on opposing ends of State Street, in Bascom Hall and the Capitol to advocate for equally polarized viewpoints of the New Badger Partnership on Tuesday.

    Nearly 100 University of Wisconsin students hosted a rally against the proposal — which would make UW independent from the UW System — at the main administration building, Bascom Hall. The rally culminated in an impromptu meeting with Chancellor Biddy Martin, while members of a student organization advocated in favor of the plan by meeting with legislators at the Capitol.

    Mexican Electrical Workers go to Wisconsin

    April 1, 2011
    Mexican Electrical Workers Union

    For Immediate Attention

    Wednesday, March 30, 2011

    Contacts:        
    Ignacio Meneses 313-318-5159
    Teresa Gutierrez 917-328-6470

    A delegation of workers affiliated with the Mexican Electrical Workers Union of (SME) headed by Jose Humberto Montes de Oca, Secretary of the Interior of this organization, will participate this next Friday April 1st in the massive protest against the law that annuls the Collective Bargaining of the workers of the public services of Wisconsin to endorse their struggle. 

     

    Test

    March 22, 2011
    TestTest

    Test

    CAP TIMES: National veterans group hosts worker solidarity march Saturday

    March 19, 2011
    Judith Davidoff

    The morning the state Assembly was debating Gov. Scott Walker's controversial bill to sharply curtail collective bargaining rights for public workers, protesters and police got into a brief tussle at the Martin Luther King Boulevard entrance to the Capitol because nobody, including Rep. David Cullen, D-Milwaukee, was being allowed into the building. At one point, a man yelled out to the police officers guarding the doors: "This is what we get for fighting for democracy in Iraq?"

    PR WATCH: Judge issues temporary restraining order blocking implementation of Walker's union-busting bill

    March 18, 2011
    Brendan Fischer

    A second judge has castigated Wisconsin Republicans for excluding the public from the legislative process. Dane County Judge Maryann Sumi has issued a temporary restraining order blocking implementation of Governor Walker's union-busting bill on grounds that the conference committee's rushed passage of the bill on March 9 likely violated state Open Meeting laws. 

    Bill Cronon investigates the connections between right wing foundations and the Walker agenda

    March 15, 2011
    Bill Cronon

    A Study Guide for Those Wishing to Know More

    After watching the sudden and impressively well-organized wave of legislation being introduced into state legislatures that all seem to be pursuing parallel goals only tangentially related to current fiscal challenges–ending collective bargaining rights for public employees, requiring photo IDs at the ballot box, rolling back environmental protections, privileging property rights over civil rights, and so on–I’ve found myself wondering where all of this legislation is coming from.

    SCFL endorses taking steps to prepare for a general strike

    March 9, 2011
    South Central Federation of Labor

    TO: All Affiliates of the South Central Federation of Labor

    FROM: JimCavanaugh,President

    SUBJECT: SCFL Motions on the General Strike and the Governor’s Budget Repair Bill

    VIDEO & AUDIO: March 5th "We are Wisconsin!" Rally

    March 5, 2011
    Ryan Heraly and Tona Williams

    On March 5, 2011, 40-50,000 Wisconsinites rallied under the banner of the Wisconsin Wave for full funding for our public sector, the right to collective bargaining, abolishing corporate constitutional rights, and expanding democratic power and participation. A diverse lineup of speakers and musicians regaled the crowds from the stage, including Kabzuag Vaj, Matt Nelson, Lelan Pan, Dave Cieslewicz, Paul Soglin, Rep. Kelda Helen Roys, Congresswoman Tammy Baldwin, Jennifer Feyerherm, Ben Manski, John Nichols, Will Williams, and Michael Moore, as well Michelle Shocked, Ryan Bingham, VO5, and Jon Langford. MC's included Patrick Depula, Tag Evers, Sarah Manski, and Ben Manski.

    AFSCME Report on Gov. Walker’s 2011-2013 State Budget Proposal

    March 4, 2011
    Susan McMurray, AFSCME government relations

    On March 1, 2011, the governor introduced his budget bill as 2011 Assembly Bill 40 (AB 40) and 2011 Senate Bill 27 (SB 27). They are identical companion bills. The bills were introduced by the Joint Committee on Finance, and both bills have been sent before the Joint Committee on Finance. They have also been referred to the Joint Survey Committee on Tax Exemptions because legislative rules require that committee to review any bill that creates tax exemptions.

    Additional Information: 

    To read the rest of this report download the attached PDF's below

    PR WATCH writes about the Republican's legally questionable power grabs

    March 4, 2011
    Mary Bottari

    The Wisconsin State Capitol has erupted in a torrent of lawlessness this week that schoolchildren will be reading about for years. No, I don't mean rowdy protests resulting in mass arrests. Even though some 300,000 people have visited the capitol in the last two weeks, the crowds have been peaceful and fun; no arrests have been reported. I mean the convulsion of lawlessness that has seized Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker and the Republican leadership -- a track record that would make Richard Nixon proud.

     

    Madison rabbi says budget "repair" bill goes against Jewish values

    March 1, 2011
    Laurie Zimmerman

    MADISON, Wis. (JTA) -- More than 100 Jews from all three Madison synagogues gathered Feb. 25 to celebrate Shabbat with services in the Wisconsin State Capitol. Four Madison rabbis led the services for the community members who had crammed into the North Gallery.

    Below us, the Capitol Rotunda was teeming with energy -- protesters from all over the state were waving signs of opposition to Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s proposed budget repair bill.

    MOTHER JONES gives historical and political context to the events in Wisconsin

    March 1, 2011
    Kevin Drum

    IN 2008, A LIBERAL Democrat was elected president. Landslide votes gave Democrats huge congressional majorities. Eight years of war and scandal and George W. Bush had stigmatized the Republican Party almost beyond redemption. A global financial crisis had discredited the disciples of free-market fundamentalism, and Americans were ready for serious change.

    Or so it seemed. But two years later, Wall Street is back to earning record profits [3], and conservatives are triumphant [4]. To understand why this happened, it's not enough to examine polls and tea parties and the makeup of Barack Obama's economic team [5]. You have to understand how we fell so short, and what we rightfully should have expected from Obama's election. And you have to understand two crucial things about American politics.

     

    CAP TIMES: Rep. Roys denied access to Capitol Monday

    February 28, 2011
    Steven Elbow

    State Rep Kelda Helen Roys, D-Madison, says she was denied access to the Capitol at several entrances this morning because she refused to show her Capitol ID card.

    "I said I'm a representative, but I don't feel you have any legal basis for restricting my access whether I have a Capitol ID or not," she says.  "And they said, 'Our orders are that no one gets in this building unless they have a Capitol ID.'"

    DAILY KOS examines possible unconstitutionality of closing the Capitol

    February 28, 2011
    mandoliniment

    Ok, this is going to be a long one, so bear with me.

    Initial background: there is a quote in circulation that purports to be from the Wisconsin Constitution, reading "The legislature cannot prohibit an individual from entering the capitol or its grounds". These words do not, in fact, appear in the Wisconsin constitution; Article 1 Section 4 reads, in it's entirety

    AP: Speaking to governors Obama makes general statements about not vilifying public workers

    February 28, 2011
    Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar

    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a concession over his divisive health care overhaul, President Barack Obama offered Monday to let unhappy states design alternative plans as long as they fulfill the goals of his landmark law.

    Addressing the nation's governors, Obama also challenged state chiefs who have sought to balance their budgets through weakening unions and curbing employees' benefits, telling them that they should not demonize workers.